Large-Scale Agile Frameworks: A Comparative Review

Fernando Almeida, Eduardo Espinheira

Abstract


This study aims to identify and systematically compare the main large-scale agile frameworks that companies can adopt to manage the work of large-scale and distributed teams. Through this, companies can more consciously perform a better-informed decision on the choice of the framework that best fits the practices and challenges of their organizations. This work employs a qualitative approach supported by an exploratory analysis that identifies and explores the processes of migration to a large-scale agile. In the first phase, fifteen assessment criteria for scaling agile are discussed. In a second phase, these criteria are used to perform a comparative analysis of six large-scale agile frameworks (i.e., DAD, LeSS, Nexus, SAFe, Scrum at Scale, and Spotify). The findings reveal there isn't a dominant large-scale agile framework in all dimensions. However, it is possible to identify frameworks like Nexus and Spotify that target smaller teams and offer low technical complexity. These frameworks easily accommodate changes, while there are other frameworks like SAFe and DAD that offer high levels of scalability but require more demanding and deep efforts in changing work processes in an organization.


Full Text:

PDF

References


M. Dülgerler, “Making better, more responsive organizations", In Proceedings of the PMI® Global Congress 2015 - EMEA, London, England, 2015.

S. Alsaqqa, S. Sawalha, and H. Abdel-Nabi, "Agile Software Development: Methodologies and Trend”, International Journal of Interactive Mobile Technologies, vol. 14, no. 11, pp. 246-270, 2020.

S. Lee, and H. S. Yong, "Agile Software Development Framework in a Small Project Environment”, Journal of Information Processing Systems (JIPS), vol. 9, no. 1, pp. 69-88, 2013.

T. Dingsøyr, and N. Moe, "Towards Principles of Large-Scale Agile Development: A Summary of the workshop at XP2014 and a revised research agenda”, In Proceedings of the 15th International Conference on Agile Software Development, Rome, Italy, pp. 1-9, 2014.

K. Dikert, M. Paasivaara, and C. Lassenius, "Challenges and success factors for large-scale agile transformations: A systematic literature review”, Journal of Systems and Software, vol. 119, pp. 87-108, 2016.

M. Paasivaara, B. Behm, C. Lassenius, and M. Hallikainen, "Large-scale agile transformation at Ericsson: a case study”, Empirical Software Engineering, vol. 23, no. 5, pp. 2550-2596, 2018.

F. Almeida, E. Miranda, and J. Falcão, "Challenges and facilitators practices for knowledge management in large-scale scrum teams”, Journal of Information Technology Case and Application Research, vol. 21, no. 2, pp. 90-102, 2019.

D. Marjanovic, M. Storga, S. Skec, N. Bojcetic, and N. Pavkovic, "Agile beyond software – a study of a large scale agile initiative”, In Proceedings of the Design 2018 15th International Design Conference, Dubrovnik, Croatia, pp. 2055-2062, 2018.

K. Conboy, and N. Carroll, "Implementing Large-Scale Agile Frameworks: Challenges and Recommendations", IEEE Software, vol. 36, no. 2, pp. 44-50, 2019.

S. Ambler, and M. Lines, Disciplined Agile Delivery: A Practitioner's Guide to Agile Software Delivery in the Enterprise, IBM Press, New York, 2012.

G. Schuh, E. Rebentisch, C. Dölle, C. Mattern, G. Volevach, and A. Menges, "Defining Scaling Strategies for the Improvement of Agility Performance in Product Development Projects”, Procedia CIRP, vol. 70, pp. 29-34, 2018.

M. Kalenda, P. Hyna, and B. Rossi, "Scaling agile in large organizations: Practices, challenges, and success factors”, Journal of Software: Evolution and Process, vol. 30, no. 10, pp. 1-25, 2018.

C. Larman, and B. Vodde, Large-Scale Scrum: More with LeSS, Addison-Wesley, Boston, Massachusetts, 2016.

G. Blokdyk, Large-Scale Scrum, 5STARCooks, Plano, Tx, 2018.

K. Bittner, Nexus Framework for Scaling Scrum: The Continuously Delivering an Integrated Product with Multiple Scrum Teams, Addison-Wesley Professional, Boston, Massachusetts, 2017.

P. Firat, and E. Can, "Two case studies to explore pros/cons and to assess applicability of Nexus maturity model”, African Journal of Business Management, vol. 12, no. 6, pp. 154-160, 2018.

D. Leffinhwell, Agile Software Requirements: Lean Requirements Practices for Teams, Programs, and the Enterprise, Addison-Wesley Professional, Boston, Massachusetts, 2011.

O. Turetken, I. Stojanov, and J. Trienekens, "Assessing the adoption level of scaled agile development: a maturity model for scaled agile framework”, Journal of Software: Evolution and Process, vol. 29, no. 6, e1796, 2017.

H. Kniberg, and A. Ivarsson, "Scaling Agile @Spotify with Tribes, Squads, Chapters & Guilds”, 2012, available at: https://blog.crisp.se/wp-content/uploads/2012/11/SpotifyScaling.pdf

L. Ng, " Why the Agile Method Often Fails in Big Companies", 2019, available at: https://medium.com/swlh/agilefall-the-trap-that-software-development-often-falls-into-e092165c6c28

D. Smite, N. Moe, G. Levinta, and M. Floryan, "Spotify Guilds: How to Succeed With Knowledge Sharing in Large-Scale Agile Organizations”, IEEE Software, vol. 36, pp. 51-57, 2019.

G. Hohpe, I. Ozkaya, U. Zdun, and O. Zimmermann, "The Software Architect's Role in the Digital Age”, IEEE Software, vol. 33, no. 6, pp. 30-39, 2016.

D. Strode, S. Huff, and A. Tretiakov, "The Impact of Organizational Culture on Agile Method Use”, In Proceedings of the 42th International Conference on Systems Science, Waikoloa, Hawaii, pp. 1-9, 2009.

M. Kostic, " Challenges of agile practices implementation in the medical device software development methodologies”, European Project Management Journal, vol. 7, no. 2, pp. 36-44, 2017.

A. Queirós, D. Faria, and F. Almeida, "Strengths and Limitations of Qualitative and Quantitative Research Methods”, European Journal of Education Studies, vol. 3, no. 9, pp. 369-387, 2017.

R. Gephart, " Qualitative Research and the Academy of Management Journal”, Academy of Management Journal, vol 47, no. 4, pp. 454-462, 2004.

A. Putta, M. Paasivaara, and C. Lassenius, "Benefits and Challenges of Adopting the Scaled Agile Framework (SAFe): Preliminary Results from a Multivocal Literature Review”, In: Kuhrmann M. et al. (eds) Product-Focused Software Process Improvement, PROFES 2018, Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 11271, Springer, Cham, 2018.

U. Eklund, and C. Berger, "Scaling agile development in mechatronic organizations - a comparative case study”, In Proceedings of the 2017 IEEE/ACM 39th International Conference on Software Engineering: Software Engineering in Practice Track (ICSE-SEIP), Buenos Aires, Argentina, pp. 137-182, 2017.

R. Johnson, and G. Morgan, Survey Scales: A Guide to Development, Analysis, and Reporting, The Guildford Press, New York, 2016.

A. Mersino, "There Is No Spotify Model for Scaling Agile”, 2019, available at: https://vitalitychicago.com/blog/there-is-no-spotify-model-for-scaling-agile/

J. Karlsson, " Principles of Good Large-Scale Agile”, 2019, available at: https://thenewstack.io/principles-of-good-large-scale-agile/

A. Poth, S. Sasabe, A. Mas, and A. L. Mesquida, " Lean and agile software process improvement in traditional and agile environments”, Journal of Software: Evolution and Process, vol. 37, no. 1, pp. 1-11, 2019.

D. Rigby, J. Sutherland, and A. Noble, "Agile at Scale”, Harvard Business Review, vol. May-June, 2018, available at: https://hbr.org/2018/05/agile-at-scale

S. Bambauer-Sachse, and T. Helbling, "Customer satisfaction with business services: is agile better?", Journal of Business & Industrial Marketing, In Press, 2021.

E. F. Turesky, C. D. Smith, and T. K. Turesky, "A call to action for virtual team leaders: practitioner perspectives on trust, conflict and the need for organizational support", Organization Management Journal, vol. 17, no. 4/5, pp. 185-206, 2020.

P. Maddaloni, "Agile at Scale: Comparing the Popular Scaling Frameworks", 2019, available at: https://www.6kites.com/comparison-scaling-agile-frameworks/

M. Wiesche, "Interruptions in Agile Software Development Teams”, Project Management Journal, vol. 52, no. 2, pp. 210-222, 2021.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.31284/j.jasmet.2021.v2i1.1832

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


Copyright (c) 2021 Fernando Almeida, Eduardo Espinheira

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License.

Mailing Address: Journal of Applied Sciences, Management and Engineering Technology - ITATS Institut Teknologi Adhi Tama Surabaya Jl. Arief Rahman Hakim No.100, Surabaya 60117 email: [email protected] Website : https://ejurnal.itats.ac.id/jasmet/index